7 of the Most Valuable Beanie Babies Around Today
Ty Beanie Babies are some of the most lovable and recognizable animal plushes in the world today. These little fluffy relics of the 1990s and early 2000s have enough brand recognition that one of the best cheap costumes you can make for a pet is a heart-shaped tag with that iconic logo on it.
Whether you collected these toys as a kid or got into them later in life, you may be surprised to find that certain beanie babies have some serious potential cash attached to their names. Not sure what the most valuable beanie babies are? No worries! We’ll list 7 of the most valuable ones available today.
1. Princess the Bear
The story behind this beanie baby is quite sad. Princess the Bear was released in memoriam of the late Princess Diana in October of 1997. All proceeds from purchases of this limited release went towards the Diana, Princess of Wales Memorial Fund.
This purple bear has a white rose stitched on its heart. However, seeing its popularity, Ty decided to release more copies of the bear, which diminished its value. Still, if you happen to have an almost mint condition copy of this bear from its original run, you can sell it for up to $500,000, making it one of the most valuable beanie babies on the market.
2. Bubbles
As with several of the beanie babies on this list, the value of the plush itself depends on its release date. This yellow and black striped fish first swam onto the scene in 1996 and had several adjustments made to its design. These updates and modifications led to some interesting manufacturing errors.
For instance, the 4th generation model of this beanie baby has incorrect tags attached to its tail. If this 1996 plush with incorrect tags happens to be sitting in your beanie baby collection, you have up to $129,000 in value on your hands.
3. Piccadilly Attic
While they often get discussed in terms of their collectible value today, let’s not forget that most people buy beanie babies for their kids. That explains why this charming, light-brown bear with curly fur and a red clown nose might not have been the most popular upon its release.
Coulrophobia, or being scared of clowns, is quite common amongst children after all. Their loss can turn into a major net gain for you, as Piccadilly Attic’s value has shot to around $125,000.
4. Valentino the Bear
As you might expect from the name, this simple yet romantic bear got released in 1994 for Valentine’s Day. He’s got a pure white body with an embroidered red heart and a red ribbon around his neck.
On the surface, if you have one from 1994 that’s in good condition, it might net you some cash but not crazy amounts of money. Rumors circulate that versions of this bear with printing errors on his tags sell for as much as $42,000.
However, his sister from 1998, Valentina the Bear, can also net you a tidy $1,500. So, make sure you research which of these Valentine’s Day bears you have in your collection.
5. Hippity, Hoppity, and Floppity
This trio of colorful bunnies saw their release date at the very start of 1997 and only ran in production for about a year. Hippity, the green bunny, Hoppity, the pink bunny, and Floppity, the lilac bunny, can pull in a decent chunk of change on their own. However, since they got released as part of a set, their true value rests in having the full collection on hand.
If you have all three of the bunnies, you can sell them for a tidy sum of $30,000. Talk about a major payoff for being the kind who had to have all the toys!
Despite their rarity, getting the full value you deserve on this set of rabbits can prove tricky. eBay remains one of the best ways to sell beanie babies like these, but there are other, more dedicated platforms.
6. Brownie the Bear
Now we’re getting into the real classics. Brownie the Bear was one of Ty’s original beanie babies. Due to its presence in the company’s first collection, it’s gained incredible value over the years.
If you have Brownie instead of Cubbie (its replacement), this plain brown and tan bear with no poem on its tag can bring you $20,000 in profit. That’s an amazing amount of money for what would otherwise seem like a nondescript children’s plush toy.
7. Iggy the Iguana
Ty has loosened up in recent years and released everything from spiders to insects to emojis. Iguanas and chameleons were fairly rare for plush toys when Iggy crawled onto the scene at the tail end of 1997.
So, where does this beanie baby’s value come from? Simply put, there was a major manufacturing mix-up between this plush and Rainbow the Chameleon. This led to fabric color palettes, tags, and tag locations getting swapped by accident.
If you happen to have a rainbow-print Iggy with missing text inside the tag, it could be worth as much as $15,000. That’s an incredible value for what amounts to an oopsie at the factory!
Want to Learn More About Valuable Beanie Babies and Other Collectibles?
We hope that this list of 7 of the most valuable beanie babies available today illustrated how important it is to check your old junk for collector’s value before tossing it to a thrift store or in the trash. If you found this article helpful and would like to learn more about how to determine the value of (or even sell) your collectibles, then check out the Lifestyle section of our blog! We update each day with more useful guides like this one.
